The park’s main roadway encourages speed; a redesign must slow it all down.
By Justin Davidson
On September 23, Richie O’Brien was walking his bicycle across Central Park’s East Drive at 84th Street, near the Metropolitan Museum of Art, on his way to his job as a steamfitter when another cyclist crashed into him. O’Brien died from his injuries. Less than two weeks later, a golden retriever darted out onto East Drive near the exact same spot. A 71-year-old cyclist slammed on the brakes, flew over the handlebars, and was killed.
These tragic incidents highlight a growing crisis within New York City’s most famous green space. For anyone who has biked along that stretch, crossed it on foot, or watched a pet sprint off toward traffic, the realization sets in quickly: the fact that more encounters do not result in catastrophic crashes is often just a matter of luck.
A few days after the second fatality, a visitor found themselves at East Drive and 97th Street—the very spot where, in June of last year, Salvador Nico-Garcia was thrown from his e-bike and died after colliding with a pedestrian. This time, a large group of bicycle novices led by a teacher pulled up slowly and politely paused at a crosswalk. A police van stopped alongside them. Reassured by the temporary pause in momentum, the pedestrian stepped out into the roadway to cross, only to be nearly bowled over twice: first by a speedy cyclist who sliced through the crowd on the passenger side of the police van, and then by a second rider who chose the driver’s side. Jumping back quickly, the breeze from the passing rider rushed past, underscoring the relentless danger of the corridor.
The six-mile Central Park Drive that loops around the park’s perimeter has a long and complicated history. It was originally built as a carriage road before being requisitioned for cars, later cleansed of motorized vehicles entirely, and is now a chaotic conduit for a diverse mix of one- and two-wheeled vehicles, both electrified and traditional.
During the early morning hours, flocks of road racers clad in matching jerseys treat the 20-mile-per-hour speed limit as an open challenge, viewing slower riders as mere obstacles to clear. E-bike riders gun the throttles of their silent engines, while scooter operators zip through crowds with music blaring in their ears, completely muffling the protests of startled pedestrians.
At the same time, the Drive accommodates less frantic rhythms. Joggers and power walkers occupy their own wide lanes, while families on holiday view the roadway as a safe, idyllic space for a leisurely two-wheeled amble, spreading out, swerving, and stopping abruptly to rest at the top of hills. Every now and then, a diehard inline skater can be seen sauntering along in a backward dance.
The core trouble is that members of these two massive groups—the slow and the fast—collide with bone-crushing regularity. While death remains a relatively rare result, its specter is ever-present for anyone entering the roadway.
So far, the Central Park Conservancy and the NYPD have attempted to tackle these rising threats with an ineffectual combination of public pleading, finger-wagging, and issuing only a small handful of tickets each week. In 2024, the conservancy and the city collaborated on a Safety and Circulation Study of the Drive, but ultimately implemented the least demanding of its recommendations. These measures included repainting lanes and crosswalks and stamping "Look!" signs for pedestrians directly onto the asphalt.

Unsurprisingly, those cosmetic changes did not come close to eliminating conflict or confusion. A proposed reduction of the speed limit from 20 mph to 15 mph was subsequently blocked in court, and bikers have continued to move just as fast as they did before.
Recently, Central Park Conservancy President Betsy Smith reacted to the latest fatalities by endorsing stricter enforcement of existing rules, alongside a proposal to construct new bike lanes on the impossibly narrow transverse roads. While new bike lanes could be an improvement, there is simply not enough space to squeeze them in without introducing additional hazards. None of these measures go far enough. Even physically dividing the Drive into express and local lanes, akin to a suburban highway, would only aggravate the problem for pedestrians attempting to safely cross from one side of the park to the other. In the end, making the Drive less terrifying means promoting the one concept most modern urbanites loathe: slowness.
Achieving true serenity in a heavily trafficked park is fundamentally a design problem. Other major global cities have experimented with structural solutions in green spaces roiled by speed. London installed granite rumble strips at Hyde Park Corner in an attempt to slow speeding bikes, added raised crosswalks across bike lanes at bus stops, and ran snaking, protective pathways through the residential Van Gogh Walk in Brixton. Last May, Amsterdam instituted a ban on fat-tire bikes in Vondelpark, successfully reducing the presence of that particular invasive and high-speed machine.
New York’s urban designers need a thorough catalog of these traffic-calming techniques and a genuine willingness to test them all. However, the most radical move is also the most necessary: altering the physical geometry of the Drive itself.
Cyclists, much like motorists, accelerate where they can—or rather, where the road design encourages them to pick up the pace. In Central Park, they receive permissive signals from the Drive’s broad straightaways, such as at East 84th Street, its exciting downslopes near East 97th Street, and curves wide enough to accommodate a speeding bus. All of these features need to change.
Curves should be made significantly snakier, lanes should narrow and widen at unpredictable intervals, and speed bumps and physical planters should be deliberately placed in the flow of traffic. All of these moves are guaranteed to infuriate those who value the Drive’s current openness and fluidity—most notably the road racers who consider the park their personal athletic preserve. While that perspective is understandable, Central Park can no longer grant the privilege of allowing individuals to rocket along unimpeded. Horse racing, dog racing, and NASCAR are not permitted to take over public parks and city streets; high-speed cycling should be held to the same standard.
To date, neither the city nor the conservancy seems entirely willing to view speed itself as the primary enemy, though tragic momentum may eventually force their hand. Following a runaway horse incident that killed 18-year-old Romanch Mahajan on June 17, the City Council finally took the decisive step of banning horse-drawn carriages—a policy shift that had been debated for years.
Now, the city must move away from a strictly reactive stance and reinforce Central Park’s historical role as a laboratory for urban living. As Smith noted in a recent essay, the park functions as a "proxy for how the rest of the world sees the city as a whole." She is right that friction over the use of roadways and shared paths is hardly unique to Central Park; rather, it is a frustrating byproduct of the broader, long-term effort to make New York safer and more pleasant to navigate.
As the city built out extensive bike networks, deployed Citi Bikes, and worked to curb automobile dominance, many urban advocates believed and hoped that new populations of commuters, children, seniors, and tourists on two wheels would naturally crowd out the speed demons. The expectation was that e-scooters would be a boon for people with the desire to travel but lacking the leg strength for traditional cycling. Because bikers and pedestrians are often the same people at different times of day, planners assumed their interests would naturally overlap, fostering a civil culture of the streets where New Yorkers of varying speeds, abilities, and lifestyles could share asphalt on equal terms.
Instead, the reality has devolved into a free-for-all. Sidewalks, footbridges, crosswalks, parks, esplanades, and car-free plazas—virtually every public space where pedestrians should feel entirely at ease—have been overwhelmed by a chaotic swarm of vehicles, both motorized and manual.
Vision Zero, the comprehensive set of traffic-calming goals and strategies championed by successive mayoral administrations over the past two decades, was supposed to grant pedestrians a greater sense of ownership over the public realm through wider sidewalks, better-marked intersections, clearer turns, and more rational traffic patterns. Instead, it has frequently produced the opposite effect. The classic New York pedestrian battle cry of "I’m walkin’ heah" has increasingly transformed into an even more plaintive chorus of caution.

A vast gulf remains between the fear and fury of everyday New Yorkers and the perceived indolence of city leaders, who continue to treat e-bikes as little more than a minor civic annoyance. During a City Council hearing last September, several speakers advocated for Priscilla’s Law, legislation that would require registration and license plates for e-bikes. That bill remains stalled at both the state and city levels, serving as a reasonable yet cumbersome method to bring accountability to the proliferation of anonymous machines. Officials have frequently deflected these arguments by pointing out that automobiles are statistically far more dangerous than bicycles—a fact that is objectively true, but of little comfort to someone dodging a speeding throttle-bike on a pedestrian path.
Much of the modern crisis stems from the explosive growth of app-based delivery services, which has made urban street conditions exponentially worse. Everyone who steps outside today shares the psychic cost of having a meal rushed hot to their doorstep.
Many delivery riders, particularly undocumented immigrants, value their professional invisibility, leading them to speed through the city like nocturnal creatures, moving silently and without proper lights along unpredictable paths until a collision occurs. Official regulations require these workers to wear high-visibility clothing, use functional headlights, stay off sidewalks, obey one-way street designations, and show respect for pedestrians. In practice, few adhere to these mandates. Instead, they adopt desperate risk-taking strategies, shrug off verbal reprimands, and continue flouting traffic rules under the accurate assumption that the likelihood of receiving a ticket remains remarkably low.
The city administration has frequently pointed to the unforgiving economics of delivery apps and the pervasive fear of deportation as root causes of this behavior. Rather than launching aggressive enforcement actions against vulnerable workers, officials have sought to target the corporate leadership by ensuring that delivery companies face financial repercussions for encouraging unsafe practices, as outlined in the latest Vision Zero strategic plan.
Unfortunately, negotiating with massive tech conglomerates like Uber and DoorDash requires substantial time, legal resources, and political capital. While corporate penalties may eventually materialize and prove effective, e-bike operators on the ground are growing bolder, faster, and more defiant by the day. In 2024, then-Deputy Mayor Meera Joshi proposed the creation of a Department of Sustainable Delivery—a new bureaucratic agency intended to bring order to the delivery industry by 2028. Since then, the administration has dramatically scaled back that timeline and ambition.
The city must recognize immediately, rather than waiting into the next decade, that the pervasive vulnerability felt by pedestrians is a critical quality-of-life crisis. Its true gravity cannot be measured solely by a short list of severe injuries and fatalities, nor can it be dismissed as mere perception unsupported by data. Even as overall crime drops and car crashes recede in certain corridors, New York’s streets and parks have grown increasingly hostile to those who are frail, slow, disabled, or young.
Data from 2022 shows that seniors represented less than 15 percent of New York City’s population yet accounted for approximately 45 percent of all pedestrian fatalities. Even inside the perceived sanctuary of city parks, parents and guardians are forced to keep their children tethered closely beside them, entirely out of the path of the bionic combinations of muscle and machinery barreling past.
Because Central Park is largely free of automobiles, its internal roadway can and should be utilized as a live workshop to test ways of calming the current anarchy through a coherent combination of design, enforcement, and regulation. Techniques can be trialed, evaluated, and refined within the park before being translated to city streets where cars still dominate.
For years, planners and advocates have poured immense energy into figuring out how to make bicycles move faster. Now, the city must focus that exact same ingenuity on figuring out how to slow them down. Otherwise, the public realm will grow safer in the worst possible way: because people are simply too terrified to use it.